Course Description

This course examines key writers, artists, and artistic movements from 1800 to the present day. The semester’s readings reflect cultural crises and societal changes over the past 222 years. Three tipping points will serve as thematic foci: Imperialism, Alienation, and Consumerism. Assignments include learning trips to various sites of historical and cultural significance in and around London to emphasize the Humanities’ relevance beyond the classroom. This course fulfills a single unit in each of the following BU Hub areas: Aesthetic Exploration, Historical Consciousness, Critical Thinking.

Course Rules

Plagiarism is a very serious offense in this course, at CGS, and in the wider BU community. If you’re short on time, better that you ask for an extension than fail the assignment or (worse) get suspended.

Respect me and your fellow students during class. Keep your laptop closed and your eyes on whoever’s talking—or on the text we’re talking about. Focus on people are saying and join in the discussion with insights or questions of your own.

Attendance is essential to your engagement and learning—all the more so in a class with just 12 sessions. We will meet twice a week for a class period of two hours. In order to fulfill the required course contact hours and receive course credit, all Boston University students are expected to attend each and every class session. Attendance at all class meetings as well as required out-of-classroom trips, events, and performances is mandatory! For every unexcused absence from a mandatory class meeting, trip, or event, a student’s course grade will drop one full letter grade.

Course Materials

You will need one of the books from Hum 103, and two others. All can be purchased at at Amazon via the links provided:

  • The Metamorphosis: A New Translation by Susan Bernofsky, (important that you purchase this translation!): link.
  • H.G.Wells, The Island of Dr. Moreau, as required in Social Science.
  • Carol Strickland, The Annotated Mona Lisa, 3rd edition: link.

Additional readings will be posted on on the course Blackboard page.

Grading

Grade Weighting as follows, weights out of 100 total:

  • Museum Reflection (2-3 p) 15
  • Theater Review (2-3 p) 15
  • Final Exam (combined short answer & essay format) 35
  • HW 25
  • Class Participation 10

All assignments will contribute to the students’ mastery of the Aesthetic Expression, Historical Consciousness, and Critical Thinking HUB Requirements.

Attendance penalties, as noted in the Course Rules, above.

Participation
Active participation includes speaking up in class (but not dominating the conversation), attending office hours, volunteering to read aloud, & taking an active role in group activities. Unauthorized use of electronics (cell phone, computer, etc.), tardiness, disruptive behavior, forgetting to bring assigned readings, or lack of alertness will adversely affect your class participation.

HUB Capacities

Humanities 104 is designed to achieve the following learning outcomes, per the BU HUB.

Aesthetic Exploration:

  • By surveying the art and literature of the past two centuries, this course introduces students to various modes of aesthetic exploration.  In their homework, essays and exams, students will demonstrate both knowledge and appreciation of notable works of art and literature, including the cultural contexts in which those works were created, and will ponder their ongoing relevance.
  • Through tests, written assignments, and in-class discussions, students will demonstrate the reasoning skills and vocabulary necessary to interpret works of art and literature.
  • In class discussion and in their written work, students will evaluate and analyze a wide range of artistic modes, from lyric, narrative and painting to film and comic books; as well as a wide range of artistic styles, from realism to satire, surrealism, and expressionism.

Historical Consciousness:

  • Students will learn to understand and evaluate artworks in their respective historical and cultural contexts. They will learn to use historical evidence in evaluating interpretations of artworks.
  • Through exams, writing assignments, and in-class discussions, students will demonstrate an ability to interpret primary source material (textual, visual, or aural) using a range of interpretive skills and situating the material in its historical and cultural context.
  • In surveying specific periods in the history of literature and the arts, students will demonstrate knowledge of various philosophical and religious traditions, intellectual paradigms, forms of political organization, and socio-economic forces. They will thereby learn how these have changed over time.

Critical Thinking:

  • Students will be able to analyze various forms of argumentation and interpretation when learning to understand and evaluate artworks. They will identify key elements of critical thinking, including habits of distinguishing deductive from inductive modes of inference and recognizing common logical fallacies and cognitive biases. Students will learn to distinguish empirical claims about matters of fact from normative or evaluative judgments. Students will learn to apply theories and principles in interpreting and evaluating various artworks.
  • Drawing on skills developed in class, students will be able to evaluate the validity of arguments and interpretations, including their own. Students will learn key concepts that cultivate critical thinking and rational discourse. They will also recognize the ways in which thinking about art may be shaped by values, moral character, and emotional responses.

Class 6.1

Critiques of Consumerism

Over the last 100 years, consumerism has risen to become perhaps the most widespread answer to the problem of alienation and anomie. Though family, nationality and religion remain powerful sources of identity, we define ourselves to a considerable extent by what we purchase: if not particular brands or products, then hobbies, songs, and shows we cherish. Our final class session focuses on two responses to consumerism: street art and a powerful short story by George Saunders.

Class Prep: the Politics and Aesthetics of Street Art

The Politics and Aesthetics of Street Art

Viewing:

  • Keith Haring, Crack is Wack (1986)
  • Jean-Michel Basquiat, Melting Point of Ice (1984)
  • Banksy, Parking (2010)
  • Banksy, If Graffiti Changed Anything (2011)

Reading:

Writing: Respond to ONE of the following prompts. Keep your response short, posting as a reply under the appropriate heading in the comments section:

  1. Point out a key contrast OR continuity in the street art featured above.
  2. Post a photo you took of street art here in London, then comment on how it draws upon or violates the tradition shown above.
Class Prep: Barbie and Consumerism

Purchasing Identity with Barbie and Ken

In 2024 I attended an exhibit on the history of the Barbie line of dolls and toys. It struck me as an instructive example of consumerism, for good and for bad.
Viewing:

No HW, but come to class having thought a bit about how kids play with Barbie and similar toys. What fantasies do these toys embody? What ideology do they deploy?

Class Prep: “The Semplica Girl Diaries”

Keeping Up with the Joneses

One of the most talented writers of short fiction working today, George Saunders published “The Semplica Girl Diaries” in The New Yorker in 2012. The story appeared in slightly longer form a few months later in his 2013 collection Tenth of December. Saunders’ fiction blends realism with surrealist touches to comment on contemporary life.

Reading:
George Saunders, “The Semplica Girl Diaries” (Blackboard)

Writing: Respond to ONE of the following prompts. Keep your response short, posting as a reply under the appropriate heading in the comments section:

  1. Saunders’ narrator has a peculiar voice and perspective in this story. Quote a line and use it to comment on what makes the narrator unusual.
  2. Should Saunders’ story be classed as Surrealist? Explain your answer briefly by reference to specific details from the story—and perhaps from the Surrealist Movement.

Class 5.2

The Consensus Topples

Nowadays, we think of the American political divide in geographical terms. While geography played a part in the rift that opened up in the 1960s, back then they tended to think of it in terms of age: a generation gap between conformist adults and youthful activists. That gap found expression in sexual mores, in drug use, and in musical taste as well as in politics.

Class Prep: Beat Poetry

Beat Poetry

Together with Jack Kerouac and William Burroughs, Alan Ginsberg was a founding member of the Beat Generation in the late 1950s. The Beats questioned the certitudes of consensus liberalism, highlighting the spiritual poverty of consumer culture. Many of the cultural trends we associate with the late 1960s, from free love to drug use, were initially explored by Beat writers and artists. Ten years later, Ginsberg served as an elder statesman to the Hippies of Haight-Ashbury in San Francisco during the Summer of Love (1968).

Reading:

  • Alan Ginsberg, Howl (1956) (link). Note: you may find it valuable to listen to Ginsberg read his poem, in a 1959 recording: YouTube.
  • Alan Ginsberg, “Footnote to Howl,” printed on the page immediately following: link.

    Writing: Respond to ONE of the following prompts. Keep your response short, posting as a reply under the appropriate heading in the comments section:

    1. Quote and respond to a striking image or phrase from the poem.
    2. The poem opens with something like a howl. But what’s the emotional valence of this howl: rage? joy? something else? Explain your answer by quotation of a key line or phrase.
    3. How does the poem’s emotional valence shift in its later sections? In your answer, feel free to focus on any one of the later sections, including the “Footnote.” Explain your answer by quotation of a key line or phrase.
Class Prep: Art and Activism

Artistic Transformation and Political Activism

Viewing: Corita Kent:

  • Corita Kent, that they may have life (1964)
  • Corita Kent, Rainbow Swash (1971)
  • Corita Kent, Love stamp (1985)

Viewing: Jasper Johns, Flag Paintings:

  • Jasper Johns, Flag (1954)
  • Jasper Johns, Threee Flags (1958)
  • Jasper Johns, Flag Moratorium (1969)

Viewing: Jimi Hendrix, “Star Spangled Banner” (leads into “Purple Haze”) performed at Woodstock, Aug 1969.

Writing: Respond to ONE of the following prompts. Keep your response short, posting as a reply under the appropriate heading in the comments section:

  1. Many of these artworks rework preexisting culture. Focusing on one in particular, give a rich description of what it adds, subtracts, or otherwise does to transform the original.
  2. Identify one of these pieces that strikes you as turning non-art into art. What’s at stake, culturally, in this act of transformation?
  3. Identify one of these pieces that strikes you as voicing a political message. What’s the message, and how is it being voiced?

Class 5.1

The Postwar Liberal Consensus

We live today in a nation riven nearly in two by a deep cultural and political divide. So it’s hard to imagine that the 1950s and early 60s were characterized by the opposite state of affairs. “It was an age of consensus,” writes Geoffrey Hodgson in his seminal 1976 history, America In Our Time. That consensus was ideologically liberal in the sense of believing in freedom and the future, but conservative in its complacent insistence that America had the rest of the world beat when it came to just about everything. The ideology of the liberal consensus drew in part upon the strength of the American economy in the wake of WWII. And it relied upon a willful blindness to the treatment of women and minorities.

Today we’re looking at a range of artifacts that reflect that era of consensus, even as some of them work to push the envelope. And in the next class we’ll see how the consensus foundered in the final years of the 1960s, overtaken by youthful activists who called for a more thoroughgoing rethinking of America, from antiwar activists to Black Panthers to Women’s Libbers to the Stonewall rioters.

Class Prep: Postwar American Art

Art in America After the War

New York became the art capital of the world after World War II. In the run-up to the war, artists of the avant-garde fled Europe for the safety of America. But the shift also reflected America’s rise in the world, not to mention the confidence of its often experimental artists.

Abstract Expressionism

Reading: Strickland, pp 158-161, 166.

Reading: Alastair Sooke, “Was modern art a weapon of the CIA?” BBC.com, Oct 4, 2016.

Viewing: examples of Abstract Expressionism:

  • Willem de Kooning, Woman/Verso: Untitled (1948)
  • Jackson Pollock, One: Number 31 (1950) (check out this brief MOMA video)
  • Mark Rothko, Black in Deep Red (1957)
  • Clyfford Still, PH-971 (1957)

In Class: we also discussed Willem de Kooning’s Excavation, which I’m adding here:

Excavation, painted on a 6-foot-by-8-foot canvas, was de Kooning’s largest painting through 1950.

Pop Art

Reading: Strickland, pp 172-176.

Reading: Ben Panko, “The Comic Artists Who Inspired Roy Lichtenstein Aren’t Too Thrilled About It,” Smithsonian Magazine, October 27, 2017.

Viewing: examples of Pop Art:

  • Jasper Johns, Target with Four Faces (1955)
  • Roy Lichtenstein, M-Maybe (1965)
  • Andy Warhol, Marilyn (1967)
  • Claes Oldenburg, Clothespin (1976)

Writing: Respond to ONE of the following prompts. Keep your response short, posting as a reply under the appropriate heading in the comments section:

  1. Point out a key contrast OR continuity in the art featured above.
  2. Choose an artwork from today’s assignment that you find particularly engaging. Look at it for 3 minutes, then briefly describe your experience, pointing to particular details or visual qualities that helped produce that experience.
Class Prep: A Tale of Two Panthers

The First Black Superhero

The Black Panther made his debut on the cover of the July 1966 issue of Fantastic Four: an agile, black-garbed human figure springing triumphantly above the titular characters, who were busy exploring a strange and tangled jungle of circuitry. In a curious historical coincidence, Stan Lee and Jack Kirby invented the character around the same moment as activists working to get out the Black vote in Lowndes County, Alabama, adopted a black panther as their logo. A few months later, in October 1966, that logo inspired the formation of the Black Panther Party for Self-Defense in Oakland, California.

While Marvel’s Black Panther proved popular with readers, his fame was soon eclipsed by the Party, when Black Panthers entered the California State Capitol, fully armed, to protest a proposed change in gun regulations. They made it as far as the floor of the Assembly chamber before being disarmed and escorted from the building. Party members would later claim that the group did not intend to commandeer the legislative process that day, but merely took a wrong turn on their way to the visitors gallery. Blunder or not, the optics of an armed coup were irresistible to the news media: “Capitol Is Invaded,” ran the full-width banner headline on the Sacramento Bee’s front page. Keep this context in mind as you read the two-issue story that introduced Marvel’s Black Panther.

Reading: Stan Lee and Jack Kirby, “The Black Panther” and “The Way It Began,” Fantastic Four #52 & #53.

Writing: Respond to ONE of the following prompts. Keep your response short, posting as a reply under the appropriate heading in the comments section:

  1. Can this comic-book hero be seen as an exponent of “Black Power”? Focus our attention on a particular image or plot event as evidence.
  2. Does this comic book confirm colonialist stereotypes about Africa? Or does it problematize them? Focus our attention on a particular image or plot event as evidence.

Class 4.2

The Case for Fighting Hitler

In retrospect, it’s hard to believe that there ever was a time when Americans weren’t eager to join the war against Hitler. Nowadays Nazis are the go-to enemy in movies and videogames, and WWII is regarded (by contrast to Vietnam, Afghanistan and Iraq) as the “Good War.” But Isolationism was a powerful political force in the 1930s and early 40s, campaigning under the banner of “America First!”

The following comics and movies all have a strong political bent. Does this make them propaganda, despite not being created under government sponsorship? If they are propaganda, does that make them bad art?

Class Prep: Superheroes and the War

Superheroes, Idealism, and the Case for/against War

Sometimes history moves faster than a speeding bullet.

Superman appeared on the cover of Action Comics #1 in April 1938. The character caught on with readers: a new kind of pulp hero, dressed in bright colors and blessed with superhuman powers, dedicated to making the world a better place. Within months, he had his own comic title; a year later, competitors were horning in on the action with other superheroes: Batman, Captain Marvel, Flash, and many others now forgotten.

Meanwhile Hitler began to rapidly expand Germany’s borders to the south and east, annexing Austria in March 1938 and the German-speaking parts of Czechoslovakia a few months later. German troops partitioned the remainder with Hungary in March 1939, and in September Hitler invaded Poland as part of a secret agreement with Russia’s Stalin, triggering the start of World War II.

While Great Britain and France were the first to declare war, Germany was the first to act, successfully occupying Norway, Denmark, Belgium, the Netherlands and two-thirds of France in the spring of 1940. This left Britain isolated and under aerial bombardment, as detailed at the Churchill Museum.

How would America’s new breed of costumed idealists respond to this aggression? Superman’s creators, Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster, weighed in shortly before Germany’s series of spring 1940 offensives with a story imagining their hero bringing a swift end to the conflict. Interestingly, they published this story in Look magazine rather than an ordinary comic book—certainly a detail worthy of conversation.

Other comics creators weren’t so sure about the wisdom of getting involved in “Europe’s troubles.” In the late spring of the same year Don Shelby gave a principled argument for isolationism in a science-fiction story featuring Gary Concord: the Ultra-Man.

In short, the debate between Isolationists and Interventionists wound up being carried out not only on the editorial pages of America’s newspapers, but in the comic-books sold at those same newsstands. Perhaps the most forceful instance was the cover of the first issue of Jack Kirby and Joe Simon’s new hero, Captain America, who’s shown punching Hitler’s lights out.

Reading:

  • Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster, “How Superman Would Win the War,” Look magazine, Feb 27, 1940. (Focus on the comic.)
  • Don Shelby (aka Jon L. Blummer), “Gary Concord, the Ultra-Man,” All-Star Comics #1, Summer 1940. (Focus on the first two interior pages of the comic-book story, and the last panel on the final page.)
  • Joe Simon and Jack Kirby, “Case No. 1. Meet Captain America,” Captain America #1, March 1941. (Focus on the cover as well as the first two pages of the comic-book story.)

Writing: Respond to ONE of the following prompts. Keep your response short, posting as a reply under the appropriate heading in the comments section:

  1. How do these comics characterize America’s purpose in the world? If possible, call attention to a continuity rather than to a disagreement.
  2. How do these comics imagine the role of the superhero in society/history? Call our attention to a continuity or to a disagreement.
Class Prep: Casablanca

Everybody Comes to Rick’s

Casablanca was released in November of 1942, almost a year after the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor brought an abrupt end to the political debate over whether America should intervene in the war. Yet that debate plays a central role in the movie, thematized in Bogart’s bitter declaration that he sticks his neck out for nobody.

That thematic focus can be traced to the screenplay’s origins as an unproduced stage play written in 1940, Everybody Comes to Rick’s. Warner Brothers purchased rights to the play in January 1942, shortly after the US declaration of war. Interestingly, the pair of screenwriters who adapted the play were around the same time working on series of seven propaganda films for the US Department of War titled Why We Fight.

Casablanca also provides us with the opportunity to dip a toe into a musical tradition very different from Beethoven, jazz. The movie features Dooley Wilson in the role of Sam, Rick’s loyal confidante who plays the piano in his saloon. Jazz is a distinctively American style of music; without Wilson’s presence at the piano, it’s hard to see how the place could properly be called “Rick’s Café Américain.” But jazz is also distinctively African-American, and Wilson’s relationship with Rick introduces American racial dynamics into a movie that is otherwise focused on what, if anything, America owes to the wider world.

Listening: Both of the following songs are classics, and date from the era of the movie. While both songs are upbeat, they also can be seen as offering sly commentary on race in America.

  • Duke Ellington, “Take the A Train,” clip from 1943 movie Reveille: YouTube.
  • Louis Armstrong, “Shine,” 1942 performance: YouTube.

Viewing: Michael Curtiz, Casablanca, available via BOB. (If this link doesn’t pull up the playlist, come back here and click on it a second time after you log in.)

Writing: Respond to ONE of the following prompts. Keep your response short, posting as a reply under the appropriate heading in the comments section:

  1. Call our attention to a moment in the movie that can be read as advocating for American intervention in WWII.
  2. Focusing on Rick’s relationship with Sam, what does Casablanca have to say about race? Call our attention to a particular moment and what it implies. (Feel free to reference the music of Louis Armstrong and/or Duke Ellington as well.)
  3. Focusing on the movie’s love triangle, what does Casablanca say about the role(s) of love and passion in society? Is love a force for order or for chaos?